Babalon

  1. Babalon »
  2. Marilyn Manson »
  3. Marilyn Manson News »

NK Policy Regarding Leaks & Copyrighted Materials

page 2 of 3 | 1, 2, 3

reply
  1. Tigger
    joined
    09/6/20
    posts
    449
    Thagirion
    V° - Those Who Bellow Grief & Tears
    Thursday, October 1st, 2009 - 03:08:25

    Yes, but if they are going to steal the music anyway...

     

    There is also the fact that artists don't make a majority of their money off album sales.  I'm not saying people should never buy albums because as I said I still do and am more than willing to buy every album by bands and artists I like. However, if someone downloads an album, goes to see a show by that artist, buys merchandise....isn't the artist making money still? Again, I'm saying if the alternative is that the person downloading would never go to the show and never buy merchandise because they would have never heard the album because they had no intention of buying it.

     

    Really, it boils down to the fact its not a white and black issue.  Sure, there is idiots on both sides of the argument but at the very core it's not 100% right either way. I have found TONS of music that I now own dvd's, cd's, shirts, etc of after downloading a couple songs by said artist. I should have made it clear before that I very rarely download an entire album unless it's something I really figured I would not ever expect to spend money on. Mostly, I download a few songs and if I dig them...I buy the album for the rest of the songs, better quality, art work, etc.

     

    =)

     

    Back to you saying ":( I will tell on you if you post my friend's music on here because no one buys his music" ...if people download his stuff and like it, tell him to make some kickass merchandise and play some shows if he can. Those people will go!

     

    Remember when Saul Williams gave away his cd for free with just the choice of payment and of course most people chose not to pay? Trent Reznor was upset and pissed off about it. Saul was extremely happy though as more people were listening to his album than ever before and it resulted in him selling loads of merch and having a really successful tour.

     

    "You can't change the world, you can only change yourself." - MM

  2. Galaxy Girl
    Prophette
    joined
    06/11/22
    posts
    868
    Chaigidel
    IX° - Confusion of the Power of God
    Friday, October 2nd, 2009 - 17:25:34
    Originally posted by Tigger

    Back to you saying ":( I will tell on you if you post my friend's music on here because no one buys his music" ...if people download his stuff and like it, tell him to make some kickass merchandise and play some shows if he can. Those people will go!

     

    What I was saying more or less is "on the behalf of independant artists, friends, family, and fans that don't agree with it, please don't upload an album illegally."

    And I need not "tell" my friend anything. He's been in the business for over 30 years, owned his own record label and still works very closely with a lot of independent and major label bands and artists. I'm pretty confident he doesn't need to be told to "play some shows and sell some merch". He knows how this stuff works, as do I to certain degree. 

  3. Alison
    Poetess
    joined
    09/5/14
    location
    The Desert
    posts
    4045
    Thamiel
    X° - Duality in God
    Friday, October 2nd, 2009 - 17:51:50

    ^ I'm with you, GG. My personal opinion regarding piracy is this: would I like it if I put in a full day of work which benefits my boss, coworkers & clients to then have them decide that they just would rather not pay me for said day?

  4. tuckerx
    joined
    09/6/1
    location
    Holidae Inn
    posts
    818
    Banned
    Da'ath - Babe of the Abyss
    Friday, October 2nd, 2009 - 18:37:02
    Originally posted by Alison

    ^ I'm with you, GG. My personal opinion regarding piracy is this: would I like it if I put in a full day of work which benefits my boss, coworkers & clients to then have them decide that they just would rather not pay me for said day?

    Alison alison alison..... at the end of the day people can say all these things, but in reality downloading music is alot different to that. To start with, manson is fucking rich. He says in interview that he only wants absinthe and food for his cats. 
     

    He earns the most of his income from TOURS.

     

    if you buy a CD you know shit all of that money actually goes to manson in the first place right?

     

    And the reason I'm a fan like i am now all started with a burnt ACS CD. i wouldn't of payed for it, but since i got it for free i gave it a listen and now i've brought all his CDs. So in some ways downloading helps. 

     

    I don't speak for everyone (and i hope you guys don't take this wrongly), but i openly share all my manson material with friends. I have a 6gb USB full of vids and all his CDs etc that i pass around the group and they take it. As a result one of my friends has now brought most of mansons CD's aswell.

     

    So me doing this is like robbing you of your day job? oh please. It's like not giving you a tip today, but giving you 3x that tip tommorow.

     

     

  5. Alison
    Poetess
    joined
    09/5/14
    location
    The Desert
    posts
    4045
    Thamiel
    X° - Duality in God
    Friday, October 2nd, 2009 - 19:14:55

    To use your example, not a lot of people are willing to overtip on a meal to make up for one they ate last week, but if you & your friends are, then good for you. I avoid that altogether by paying up front.

     

    Any artist can offer you their work for free, when that is all there is & that's their prerogative. When the work becomes attached to other people & grows into something larger (say, a CD) there are obviously more people's efforts to respect.

  6. William Shatner
    I can kick your ass in Tetris.
    joined
    09/9/14
    posts
    2642
    Thamiel
    X° - Duality in God
    Friday, October 2nd, 2009 - 21:39:44
    Originally posted by Galaxy Girl
    Originally posted by Tigger

    Back to you saying ":( I will tell on you if you post my friend's music on here because no one buys his music" ...if people download his stuff and like it, tell him to make some kickass merchandise and play some shows if he can. Those people will go!

     

    What I was saying was more or less is "on the behalf of independant artists, friends, family, and fans that don't agree with it, please don't upload an album illegally."

    And I need not "tell" my friend anything. He's been in the business for over 30 years, owned his own record label and still works very closely with a lot of independent and major label bands and artists. I'm pretty confident he doesn't need to be told to "play some shows and sell some merch". He knows how this stuff works, as do I to certain degree. 

     Ministry?

     

     From the way you described it it sounds as though your friend doesnt enjoy making music, he just enjoys the paycheck. Then he's the exact reason WHY I share music. Or maybe you meant something else.

     

    File sharing opens up these things to a whole new audience. Maybe this person cant affor $17.99 for fifty minutes of music. I don't buy music that doesnt have the words "Marilyn Manson" on it. Period. But my Four DevilDriver shirts and my willingness to go see them live has thrown more than enough money their way. If they, or your friend, are so greedy they absolutely have to have that 17.99, well they arent much of an artist and don't deserve my, or anyone else's admiration.

     

    They arent artists, they're a product?


  7. Galaxy Girl
    Prophette
    joined
    06/11/22
    posts
    868
    Chaigidel
    IX° - Confusion of the Power of God
    Saturday, October 10th, 2009 - 20:22:54

     You have really got things backwards here William Shatner. I can tell you know very little about the music industry. 

    Independent Music (Please Read) 

    Obviously my friend cares far more about making music than he does about making money. There’s no question. I really have no clue why you would think otherwise, when I clearly stated he makes very little money, yet has spent most of his life making music. He’s retaining creative control. That is one reason why he does have little money and as far as I’m concerned, that is what being an artists is all about. The “products” you speak of, are often the only ones able to make an actual living off this kind of stuff. It’s just common sense. It’s very much like mom and pop vs. big corporation. It works very similarly. 

  8. Ostendo Keter
    Die in my image.
    joined
    09/11/10
    posts
    385
    Banned
    Da'ath - Babe of the Abyss
    Monday, November 16th, 2009 - 23:01:17

    It's a shame to hear this, as I have always wanted to make music, but I doubt anyone would respect the work and thought I would end up putting into it. I've made it so that I will only download official free releases for a long time now, as I am quite sure that the amount of sheer will focus and determination it takes to get good enough to make your own music and get it out there takes a lot out of you. But from an artists standpoint, many people feel as though they have their own paths in life they must take. I will admit I can't handle how this world works and am trying a lot of things to exercise my will and get something out in the world eventually.

    Shit on a platter, just for you

    Something to sit in your mind and stew

    Hard-boiled, half baked, incessant decliner

    A dessert for a doormat adorned with eyeliner

    Pathetic umbrella to your own demise

    Deformed, retroactive, blindsided ( So Wise)

    Heretic hogwasher dead on the rise

    Bogged down with ignorance, doped up on pride

    DISCLAIMER : -> DO NOT  click <-

  9. DopeHatter
    dope hatter up in this bitch what nigga what fuck what yo bitches what ho straight outta compton
    joined
    09/5/28
    posts
    485
    Thagirion
    V° - Those Who Bellow Grief & Tears
    Friday, December 4th, 2009 - 00:20:00

    So, only Interscope has a hold of the old music, presumably. I don't expect to see the full discography here for download, but assuming Manson no longer has any rights and wouldn't get profit from demos and other unreleased shit actually getting released, would the policy change at all?

    "Individual rights are not subject to a public vote; a majority has no right to vote away the rights of a minority."

  10. NK
    The Sex Murderer
    joined
    06/9/9
    location
    Pandæmonium
    posts
    1803
    Deity
    Administrator
    Friday, December 4th, 2009 - 02:16:33
    Originally posted by DopeHatter

    So, only Interscope has a hold of the old music, presumably. I don't expect to see the full discography here for download, but assuming Manson no longer has any rights and wouldn't get profit from demos and other unreleased shit actually getting released, would the policy change at all?

     

    nope. M still makes profit off CD sales to continue making a living and thereby give us more art so this policy is completely unaffected. MM has full rights over all his music. Interscope is merely the conduit used to release all previous albums. all this means is that no future Marilyn Manson albums will be fucked over and censored by Interscope so we get the full vision and intent in our hands now.

     

  11. BlankPolaroid
    joined
    09/7/5
    location
    Ohio
    posts
    1153
    Thamiel
    X° - Duality in God
    Friday, January 8th, 2010 - 22:58:06
    Originally posted by NK
    Originally posted by DopeHatter

    So, only Interscope has a hold of the old music, presumably. I don't expect to see the full discography here for download, but assuming Manson no longer has any rights and wouldn't get profit from demos and other unreleased shit actually getting released, would the policy change at all?

     

    nope. M still makes profit off CD sales to continue making a living and thereby give us more art so this policy is completely unaffected. MM has full rights over all his music. Interscope is merely the conduit used to release all previous albums. all this means is that no future Marilyn Manson albums will be fucked over and censored by Interscope so we get the full vision and intent in our hands now.

    [The quote in bold]- Is just exactly what I was thinkin' and very fucking happy about, and I for one, eagerly look forward to see what will come out next.

    YOUR BRAIN IS THE GOD MODULE.
  12. Msstma
    nobody
    joined
    09/10/20
    posts
    161
    Disabled
    Da'ath - Babe of the Abyss
    Monday, February 15th, 2010 - 19:20:05

    There is a quote on the Tryptich article i want to use. It's from that interview he gave in Revolver about what the Tryptich was. Can I quote it elsewhere? like not on the boards, especially if I say where I saw it?

     

    thanks

  13. Favenris
    Work Hard & Play Hard
    joined
    08/9/27
    location
    Hatesville
    posts
    3626
    Thamiel
    X° - Duality in God
    Monday, February 15th, 2010 - 21:11:52
    Originally posted by Msstma
    There is a quote on the Tryptich article i want to use. It's from that interview he gave in Revolver about what the Tryptich was. Can I quote it elsewhere? like not on the boards, especially if I say where I saw it?


    thanks


    Are you serious? Why would that be a problem at all?

  14. Msstma
    nobody
    joined
    09/10/20
    posts
    161
    Disabled
    Da'ath - Babe of the Abyss
    Monday, February 15th, 2010 - 22:38:50

    .

  15. Man_That_You_Fear
    joined
    10/3/8
    posts
    14
    Banned
    Da'ath - Babe of the Abyss
    Monday, March 8th, 2010 - 04:15:57

    It is sad that Marilyn Manson the band is not acknowledged as much as the man himself. Twiggy, Pogo, and Ginger Fish are the most important members aside from Manson. But we have sadly lost our favorite band because Manson is now a drug addicted alcoholic. He could not create a powerful album like Holy Wood or Antichrist Superstar again unless he gets his life back together and puts the make up back on. The band is sadly a joke now because of Eat Me, Drink Me and The High End of Low.

  1. Babalon »
  2. Marilyn Manson »
  3. Marilyn Manson News »
reply

page 2 of 3 | 1, 2, 3

  1. Marilyn Manson
    1. Marilyn Manson News
    2. Marilyn Manson General Chat
    3. Marilyn Manson Tour
    4. The High End Of Low | Tour Dates
    5. Marilyn Manson Analysis
  2. General / Personal Chat
    1. General Chat
    2. Philosophy & Writings
    3. "Degenerate" Art
    4. "Degenerate" Film / Movies
    5. "Degenerate" Musik
    6. The Occult
    7. Current Events & Politiks
  3. NACHTKABARETT Site News
    1. Nachtkabarett Translations
    2. Site Updates
    3. Questions / Suggestions